| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 3 (No. 2) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 139-152 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Gagasan etis buku Samma Theologiae Thomas Aquinas sangat kaya. Kekayaan idenya kerap disebut sebagai pondasi etika f,lsafat kristiani. Filsafat Thomas memang menjadi emblem rasionalitas kekdstenan (Gereja Katolik). Tulisan ini menelisik bebetapa tema dalam buku yang menjadi ringkasan tema-tema etis, filosofis, teologis sepanjang masa itu, Summa Tbeologiae. Diaiukan di sini delapan tema: konsep akal budi praktis Aristotelian, kehendak manusia untuk berbuat jahat, baik sebagai obfek kehendak, prinsip dottble ffict, definisi hukum, habit-airtru-reaton, definisi keadilan, soal reproduksi dan ilmu pengetahuan modern. Uraian setiap tema merepresentasi aktivitas membaca dao menganalisis filsafat Thomas, yang di sini sedng diurai dalam dialognya dengan filsafat Aristoteles, Plato, Sokrates dan yang lain. Masing-masing tema melukiskan point-poinl fundamental etika Thomistik. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 3 (No. 2) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 125-137 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | What criteria should we use to make our moral judgments? In response to this basic and practical question we often face in our daily lives, in this article I would like to present and evaluateJohn Dewey's criteria for moral judgment which he expounded in his pragmatic ethics. This article rvill be divided into three parts. First, different from traditional teleological ethics which consider the certain human final end as the ultimate criterion for judging the morality of an act, in Dewey's view, ao act should be judged morally good if it achieves its specific and cootextual end-in-vie'.v There are many ends-in-view as there are many moral acts, and an end-in-view can never be determined apatt from the actually available means to achieve it. Second, for Dewey, an act is considered good or morally dght if it does in practice lead to the human self-realization of the agent. What constitutes an agent's human self-realization can never be determined in an a priori way. Unlike Aristode and Thomas Aquinas, who consider human self-realizattort as closely related to what is essential to human nature, namely his/her being a rational and social animal, Dewey rejects essentialism with respect to human natute in understanding human being. He understands human self-tealizaliot within the context of the human dynamic process of "ftansactions" with the person's concrete environment. Third, as an evaluation of Dewey's vieq fitst of all, it will be shown how Dewey, despite his being a modernist and a strong believer in science and the scientific method, has antedated postmodern tenets by rejecting essentialism and universalism while embracing the plurality of moral values and the contextuality of moral judgments. By emphasizing the importance of social values and one's integration into one's community, possibly under the influence of Hegel's concept of Sittlighkeit, Dewey's moral theory also has some communitarian elements. Theo, it uill be shown how Dewey's theory of moral iudgment, being pragmatic and utilitarian, may be against the principle of justice and does not take seriously the importance of motivation in making moral judgments. Finally, an appreciation of Dewey's positive approach in moral education is put forward. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 3 (No. 2) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 109-123 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | This atticle explores the challenging moral philosophy of Iris Murdoch. I\{urdoch exposes post-Kantiao "existentialist-behaviorist" moral philosophy as shockingly misguided. By blindly following the dogma of the pure factuality of outer realiry post-Kantian philosophy is forced to put the whole question of morality into the act of choosing of the will. But this account of morality is faulty on several points. It does oot take into account what modern psychology says about the paralysing self-centeredness of the ego, nor does it account for the fact of moral development. Following Simone Weil, Mutdoch shows that moraliry fust of all, has something to do with giving attention to outside reality. Freedom, then, does not consist in the fitst place in choosing this or that, but in overcoming natural self-centeredness and becoming able to rea people or situations in "a just and loving way". Often at the moment of deciding what to do, the answer has zbeady become clear. Grorr,th in moraliry thus, means becoming free from natural self-centeredness and being able to see reality better and better. Murdoch explains this process, following Plato, as propelled by the attraction of the "idea of the Good". The article, then, discusses Murdoch's emphatic refusal to connect this idea of the Good with God. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 3 (No. 1) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 61-74 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Pada zaman ini kita meniadi semakin sadar akan keragaman keyakinankeyakinan religius serta pengalaman-pengalaman kultural kita. Bersamaan dengan itu, kita sadari pula bahwa kesenjarngan antara mereka yangkaya dengan yang miskin tidak berkurang; sebaliknya iustru meniadi semakin menganga. Kita mendapatkan diri kita berada dalam persimPangan ialan dari pengalaman ini: di satu sisi kita berada dalam pluralitas religius dan kultural, dan di sisi lain begitu besarnya iumlah orang yang hidup serba kekurangan yang tinggal dalam pluralitas religius dan kultural tersebut. Dari pengalaman dasariah ini, melalui makalah ini penulis bertujuan untuk memperdalam identitas kristiani kita bedandaskan pada Infil Yesus Kristus tanpa melihatnya sebagai suatu halangan untuk berelasi dengan mereka yang hidup berdampingan dengan kita. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 3 (No. 1) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 43-59 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Tulisan ini berisi 'peta'peraturan-Peraturan yang berhubungan dengan kebebasan bengamzdi Indonesia semasa Orde Baru. Peta ini disusun berdasarkan cakrawala hukum, sehingga bersandar pada hirarki perundang-undangan yang berlaku pada masa itu. Peta akan dimulai dari kerangka ideologis sebagai lapisan luar dan diakhiri dengan kerangka eksekutifpada kerangka terdalam. Pada lapis ideologis, akan dilihat bagaimana sila pertama Pancasila yang berbunyi Ketuhanan Yang Mahaesa pada dasarnya sudah memPersemPit makna kebebasan beragama dalam arti luasnya. Kemudian, batas kebebasan itu pun makin sempit pada dataran konstitusional dengan membatasi 'isi'dari kebebasan itu. Selaniutnya,pada penerapannya pada tingkat perundang-undangan dan peraturan, dan lebih lagi pada tingkat eksekutif, penyempitan itu makin kelihatan. Dengan kata lain, makna kebebasan beragama semakin sempit dipahami dan diterapkan pada level yang lebih praktis. Dari peta ini diharapkan tedihatnya suatu alur yang lebih gampang dievaluasi dan suatu 'potret'yang lebih gampang dilihat. Beberapa catatan krttis akan diberikan pula pada masing-masing kerangka. Tentu, harapannya adalah bahwa generasr sesudah Orde Baru dapat belajzr banyak untuk langkah ke depan di bidang ini. I(arena itu, beberapa usulan pemikiran )uga disampaikan. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 3 (No. 1) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 35-42 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | As progress in science continues to reveal previously unimagined complexities, many highly regarded scientists revisit the difficult and compelling question of the origin of life in our universe. As mathematicians, biologists or philosophers of science, they explore the possibiliry of developing a reliable method for detecting intelligent design, and they examine evidence for. design,, in Iife and the universe. In this context, Micheal J. Behe discusses the implications for evolutionary theory of what he calls "irreducibly complex" biochemical systems. This paper intends to limit itself to his argumentation in favour of the empirical evidence of the presence of "intelligent designs" in nature and thus reinstate the notion of design within science. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 3 (No. 1) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 19-33 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Based upon the classificatory framework and basic ideas borrowed from Ian G. Barbour's book Etbics fu an Age of hchology, this article is an attempt to study the impact of technology on human life from three different viewpoints. First, under the heading of "Technology As Liberator", technology is considered as a boon bringing a very positive impact on human life. Several benefits of technology for human well-being and reasons for being optimistic about it will be pointed out. Second, under the heading of "Technology As A Threat", technology is viewed as a bane; several negative consequences of modern technology and several reasons for the need to be alert to its possible dangers will be considered. Third, under the heading of "Technology As Instrument of Power", the ambiguiry of technology is emphasized. Whether technology is a boon or a bane will very much deptind upon the kind of power that determines its direction. At the end of the article some important conclusions will be suggested. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 3 (No. 1) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 1-17 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Masalah identitas pribadi merupakan isu yang penting, bukan saja daram pertanggungiawaban moral, melainkan juga daiam diskursus psikologis seperti kepribadian ganda dan hilang ingatan, serta kepercayaan religius mengenai keabadian jiwa dan reinkarnasi. Tulisan ini membahas pandanganJohn l-ocke mengenai identitad pribadi yang dibangun atas distingsi antara pengada bertubuh dan kesadaran. Bagi Locke, identitas pribadi seorang pengada rasional atau manusia terkandungdalam kesadaran, baik terhadap diri sendiri maupun terhadap dunia sekitar. Identitas pribadi seorang manusia bersifat kontinu sejauh kesadaran dapat mengapropriasi (menjadikan sebagai milik) berbagai peristiwa dalam hidupnya. Filsuf Thomas Reid dan Anthony Flew memperlihatkan berbagai kontradiksi dan masalah dengan pemahaman Locke ini. Dalam pandangan penulis, locke ridak menyamakan kesadaran dengan ingatan, seperti dikritik oleh kedua filsuf di atas, melainkan hanya menekankan sifat apropriasi dari kesadaran. Akan tetapi, pandangan locke memuat banyak masalah, misalnya, distingsi yang patut dipertanyakan antara manusia (a human being) dan pribadi (person), serta ketidakielasan relasi antara kesadaran dan jiwa. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 2 (No. 2) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 173-192 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | In the history of the church we find some theologians, being the sons of their time, express the view "exfta ecclesiam nulla salus,, (no salvation outside the Chuch)' The institutional leaders of the Catholic ch.rrch later reduced and identified the wotd "church" with the Catholic church, the ecumenical council, even the pope himself. The political conflict of interest and powet between the religious leaders and those of civil institutions made this simpmea understanding of the Chuch a crucial issue, especially from the chutch ,ia.. m the Middle Ages, for instance, the church was practically the only voice in the spiritual and moral fields. when the hegemony of the catholic Church begins to fall apan and the plurality of religions becomes an undeniable fact, how-ever, the church is forced to reintelpret its views, doctrines, and attitudes. In truth, itis ,rot easy! The Second Vatican Council Ptomotes a fundamental revision of its view in relation to the concept of human salvation in general. on this view the claims of superiority and being the only possessor of re.ligious truth should be abandoned. Theological reflections in the Catholic Chutch have since shown optimistic views about human salvation. They are articulated, among others, in the distinction between the substance of the faith and its historical exptessions. For this reason, the study of the view "no salvation outside the Church,, ftom the historical-theological perspectives is necessary. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | - |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Diskursus: Jurnal Filsafat Teologi |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | 2 (No. 2) |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 157-172 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | After Immanuel Kant, trre notion of freedom has acquired a ftanscendental status. It means that without freedom as a condition, it world be impossible to speak about a truly human action. Human and morar actions cannot be conceived without ptesupposing the existence of fteedom. Is this claim applicable to oru act of faith as well? Are we allowed to believe in a God who does not take I human freedom into account? Are we truly ftee before the Almighty and the omniscient? In this paper I will present the struggle of some modetn theologians ovet this issue. More precisely, I would like to introduce their efforts to appropriate modern thoughts about freedom into their theologies. It is, of cou.rse, open ro debate whethet or not they are successful with the project or whether the essential characteristics of Christian faith have been lost in such an enterprise. yet one thing is clear to them: without making sufficient room for freedom, the modern critiquf that heteronomy is dangetous for the life of faith and theology would be unavoidable. |