| Nama Pengarang | : | Batson, C. Daniel. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 517-522 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | R. B. Cialdini, S. L. Brown, B. P. Lewis, C. Luce, & S. L. Neuberg (1997) present data that they claim challenge the empathy-altruism hypothesis by providing evidencen that the effects of empathy on helping are due to self-other merging. Despite S. L. Neuberg et al.`s (1997) effort at reassurance, doubt remain about the meaning of these data because they were obtained using scenario produceres and confounded manipulations. Using less questionable methods, C. D. Batson et al. (1997) failed to find evidence that empathy-induced helping was due to self-other merging. At a more fundamental level, the Cialdini et al. challenge rests on an apparent misunderstanding of the empathy-altruism hypothesis and, as a result, of appropriate means to test it. Finally, the question of whether empathy leads to anything more than superficial helping is addressed. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Cialdini, Robert B.; Brown, Stephanie L.; Lewis, Brian P.; Luce, Carol; Neuberg, Steven L. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 481-494 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Important features of the self-concept can be located outside of the individual and inside close or related others. The authors use this insight to reiinterpret data previously said to support the empathy-altruism model of helping, which asserts that empathic concern for another results in selflessness and true altruism. That is, they argue that the conditions that lead to empathic concern also to a greater sense of self-other overlap, raising the possibility that helping under these conditions is not selfless but is also directed toward the self. In 3 studies, the impact of empathic concern on willingness to help was eliminated when oneness-a measure of perceived self--other overlap--was considered. PAth analyses revealed further that empathic concern increased helping only through its relation to perceived oneness, thereby throwing the empathy-altruism model into question. The authors suggest that empathic cocern affects helping primarily as an emotional signal of oneness. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Davies, Martin F. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 574-583 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Cognitive-response analysis was carried out to investigate people`s acceptance of personality feed-back. In 3 studies with 223 male and female college students 18-38 years old, participants generated more confirming than disconfirming evidence for personality feedback. Availability of confirmatory evidence was found to be closely related to the related to the rated accuracy of the feedback. Both rated accuracy and amount of confirmatory evidence were greater for general than specific and for true than false feedback. Analyses of covariance showed that availability of confirmatory evidence accounted for the effects of general versus specific and true versus false feedback on rated accuracy. Findings are discussed in terms of the use of positive test strategies and the influence of confirmatory evidence retrieval on working self-concepts. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Schmutte, Pamela S.; Ryff, Carol D. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 549-559 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Because measures of personality and well-being share common affective underpinnings and items, previously reported links between these domains may be tautologival. To explicate the connections between personality and well-being, 2 samples of midlife adults (N = 215 and N = 139) completed measures of personality (NEO Five-Factor INventory; P. T. Costa & R. R. McCrae, 1992) and psychological well-being (C. D. Ryff`s, 1989b, Psychological Well-Being [PWB] inventory) that were maximally distinct, both conceptually and methodologically. Analyses included additional controls for source overlap, common affective underpinings, and shared item content. Distinctive personality correlates were observed for the 6 PWB outcomes: self-acceptance, environmental mastery, and purpose in life were linked with Neuticism (N) Extraversion (E) and Conscientiousness (C); personal growth was linked with Openness to Experience (O) and E; positive relations with others was linked with Agreeableness (A) and E; autonomy was linked with N. Psychological wellness and its personality correlates may be more complex than prior studies suggest. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Batson, C. Daniel; Sager, Karen; Garst, Eric; Kang, Misook; Rubchinsky, Kostia; Dawson, Karen. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 495-509 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Two experiments tested the idea that empathy-induced helping is due to self-other merging. To manipulate empathy,half of the participants in each experiment received instructions to remain objective while hearing about a young woman in need (low-empathy condition),and half received instructions to imagine her feelings (high-empathy condition). To check generality of the empathy-helping relationship, half in each empathy condition learned that the young woman was a student at their university (sharred group) membership, and half learned that she was a studentat a rival university (unshared group membership). Self-reported empathy for and wilingness to help the young woman were assessed, and 3 measures of self-other merging were taken. In each experiment, an empathy-helping relationship was found, unqualified by group membership, that could not be accounted for by any the merging measures. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Hatchett, Lena; Friend, Ronald; Symister, Petra; Wadhwa, Nand. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 560-573 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Chronic illness places considerable burdens on patients and their interpersonal with families. In this study, patients` perceptions of family and, medical staff expectations regarding responsibility for care and routine functions were examined. The authors hypothesized that a patient`s perceived inability to meet others` expectations about coping with illness would lead to poorer adjustment. Forty-two chronically ill patients were assessed prospectively for perceptions of others` expectations, social support, and psychological adjustment. Findings confirmed that expectations predicted subsequent decreases in psychological adjustment over a 3-month period, even when social support was controlled. A test of the reverse hypothesis showed that poorly adjusted patients did not misperceive others` expectations. Theoretical interpretations of the findings and their relation to social support research are discussed. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Strack, Fritz; Mussweiler, Thomas. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 437-446 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Results of 3 studies support the notioin that anchoring is a special case of semantic priming; specifically, information that is activated to slove a comparative anchoring taask will subsequently be more accessible when participants make absolute judgments. By using the logic of priming research, in Study 1 the authors showed that the strength of the anchor effect depends on the applicability of activated information. Study 2 revealed a constrast efffect when the activated information was not representative for the absolute judgment and the targets of the 2 judgment task were suficiently different. Study 3 demonstrated that generating absolute judgments requires more time qhen comparative judgments include an implausible anchor and can therefore be made without relevant target information that would otherwise be accesible. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Shah, James; Higgins, E. Tory. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 447-458 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | The authors propose that a promotion focus involves construal of achievement goals as aspirations whose attainment brings accomplishment. Commitment to these accomplishment goals is characterized by attempts to attain the highest expected utility. In contrast, a prevention focus involves construal of achievement goals as responsibilities whose attainment brings security. Commitment to these security goals is characterized by doing what is necessary. The different nature of commitment to accomplishment goals versus security goals is predicted to influence the interactive effect of goal expectancy and goal value on goal commitment, as evident in both task performance and decision making. Four studies found that the classic positive interactive effect of expectancy and value on goal commitment increases with a promotion focus and decreases with a prevention focus. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Gaines Jr., Stanley O.; Panter, A. T.; Lyde, Michael D.; Steers, W. Neil; Rusbult, Caryl E.; Cox, Chante L.; Wexler, Michael O. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 610-623 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | Two studies assessed the goodness of fit of ideal, quasi-, and noncircumplex models of interpersonal traits. Study 1 (N = 132) represents a secondary data anlaysis using J.S. Wiggin`s (1979) original Interpersonal Adjectives Scales (IAS) and reported by J.S. Wiggins, J.H. Steiger, and L. Gaelick (1981). Study 2 (N = 401) represents a primary data using Wiggins`s revised IAS (J.S. Wiggins, P. Trapnell, & N. Phillips, 1988). Results of both studies indicated that a quasi-circumplex model provided a better fit to the correlational data than did either ideal or noncircumplex models Also, in Study 2, results for a subsample (n = 113) indicated that an ideal circumplex model yielded a significant positive path coeficient from Nurturance to interpersonal trust (J.K. Remple, J.G. Holmes, & M.P. Zanna, 1985) but from Dominance to interpersonal trust, whereas a quasi-circumplex model yielded significant positive paths from both Dominance and Nurturance to interpersonal trust. |
| Nama Pengarang | : | Neuberg, Steven L.; Cialdini, Robert B.; Brown, Stephanie L.; Luce, Carol; Sagarin, Brad J.; Lewis, Brian P. |
| Nama Majalah/Jurnal | : | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology |
| Volume / Nomor Edisi | : | - |
| Nomor Halaman | : | 510-516 |
| Abstraksi Narasi | : | To propely test the hypothesis that empathy-associated helping is altruistic, one needs to (a) consider plausible nonaltruistic alternatives for the observed empathy-helping effects, (b) validly and reliably measure these nonaltrustic altrnatives, and (c) examine whether the empathy-helping relationship remains after removing the effects of the full complement of reasonable nonaltruistic alternatives. C. D. Batson, K. Sager, E. Garst, M. Kang, K. K, Rubchinsky, and K. Dawson (1997) failed to meet these criteria. New data, and reanalyses of existing data, bolster the case that self-other overlap--a nonaltruistic motivator--underlies the asociation between empathy and costly helping. At best, empathy per se leads to superficial helping. In a postcript, the authors comment briefly on C. D. Batson`s (1997) reply to this comment and, given his remarks, speculate as to whether the empathy-altruism formulation is even relavant to understanding meaningful forms of help. |